Make Your Own Pythagorean Cup

My parents recently went to Greece. They brought me back a souvenir—a practical joke cup called a “Pythagorean cup.” The legend behind the cup is that Pythagoras or one of the Pythagoreans invented this cup to prevent gluttony. The vessel looks like a cup with an odd pillar in the center. When you fill it up, it holds the liquid as expected. But when it gets too full, all the liquid drains out through a hole in the base.

The key to the trick is that there is a hole at the bottom of the post that leads to a pipe that runs up through the post and down through the base of the cup. As the cup fills, so does the pipe. When the liquid gets to the top, it flows down the pipe and gravity does the rest. The pipe acts as a siphon much as the plumbing does in a modern toilet.

Credit: Nevit Dilmen

Here’s a video of me using the cup and me using a Pythagorean cup that I made.

To make the cup, I pushed a bendy straw through the bottom of a styrofoam cup. It was bent over on the inside so that the opening of the straw was at the base of the cup. (I also put a bead of clue around the hole in the cup so that the liquid wouldn’t leak out around the straw.) It worked beautifully!

If I were a talented potter or had any skills in designing objects for a 3D printer, I’d make a mug with the tube running through the handle. Here’s what I have in mind. If any of you make one, send me a photo—or better, a video—or better still, the real thing!

As for the name “Pythagorean cup”: Do any math/physics/Greek historians have information about the history of this cup? Based on nothing but a gut feeling, I highly doubt this was created by Pythagoras. But I’d definitely be interested in learning the source of this attribution.

Update: On January 1, I received a printable STL file from Pablo Untroib from Argentina. I haven’t had a chance to print it yet. But Pablo did, and it is fantastic. See his video below. He said that when it is sitting on a flat table, it may not leak, but when you pick up the cup, it starts pouring out. A great prank cup!

Further update: On January 4, I received an email from blogger James Stanley who also created a Pythagorean cup—one with the slightly modified design shown below. He wrote about it on his blog. It looks fantastic—I’ll have to print that one too!]

2 Comments Add yours

  1. Katerina Reppa says:

    Bad design … Your design …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s